The Tao of Gaming

Boardgames and lesser pursuits

Some Tofurkeys

Happy Thanksgiving (for non-Americans, have a good day at work).

I’ve mainly been playing bridge recently, but a few new games have popped up.  In honor of the day, I’m labeling them Tofurkeys. Not horrible, but something a bit off.

Manhattan Project — Now that I’ve played this twice (once with the right rules) I think it’s a reasonably clever idea (worker placement where you must take an action to retrieve workers), but the implementation has some issues. It’s not sufficiently better than many other games to grab me, but it’s fine.

Article 27 — As with any negotiation, one player can give away the farm. Additionally, you may be in a position (due to the random draw) where you get -4 points if Red passes, but everyone else scores positive point, which puts you at a disadvantage. But the game takes 45 minutes with most of it actual play.

Escape — The world didn’t need a cooperative dice game, but it got one. Still, it’s loud and fast.

The Great Zimbabwe — A reasonable game I don’t like. In particular, this is too much of an abstract and suffers from the “You must make your big decisions early, when you don’t know what’s going on.” But because it’s luckless (apart from setup), everyone is deep in thought about … something. I’d rather play Sheepland, which I suspect lends itself to a similar opaque analysis, but everyone plays fast because it has dice.

I rate all of the above Indifferent, but playable (mainly due to novelty). Article 27 is my favorite, but none are likely to enter a solid rotation unless the rest of the group loves them.

I haven’t actually played Coup, but I’m planning on rectifying that soon and I think it will be a fine (if minimalistic) game. Looks like “Hoax done right”

Anyway, I’m off to commit some foodcrimes.

Advertisements

Written by taogaming

November 22, 2012 at 12:37 pm

Posted in Session Reports

2 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Have you really had tofurkey? We found Tofurkey to be Fluxx-level bad. (If there’s nothing else available, you can pretend it is food/game, and it helps if you have a lot to drink…)

    Frederic Bush

    November 22, 2012 at 1:32 pm

    • No, I’ve never had tofurkey. But if turkey wasn’t avaialable and the rest of the food was, it was no big loss. So I stand by my metaphor.

      taogaming

      November 24, 2012 at 10:50 am


Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: