The Tao of Gaming

Boardgames and lesser pursuits

Lost Valley Initial Thoughts

I got to try Lost Valley last night. This is a few years old, but was never distributed in the US (I suppose the on line stores may have it), so it didn’t get a wide audience. I’d never seen it until recently, which is mildly surprising. Anyway, you and the other players are panning for gold.

The board starts off with just a big starting piece. Your pawns move along the ‘edges’ (except for the trading post on the starting piece), and whenever you come to unexplored area you flip up some rhomboids (?) to build the world. If you create a triangle-gap, there are triangle tiles as well … these are ‘better.’ (This image explains it better than I can).

You can carry some resources (6 spaces worth). You start with tools, food and lumber, which you spend to do certain actions. On your turn you get to move 1 space (two if you follow the river) and an action, in either order. The most basic action is panning for gold, which costs food. Mining for gold (in the mountains) also costs lumber, but you have to build the mine.

The tricky thing is that in may spots, you have to spend an action (and equipment) to prepare. For example, to get gold out of the mountains you have to make a mine. To get gold out of the plains, you need to divert a stream. But once the mine is made (stream diverted, etc) then anyone can use it. So if you build a mine, any prospector nearby will run up and grab some gold.

The resource management works reasonably well. You need food to pan for gold (presumably you are out there for a long time), lumber to get gold out of mines, tools are useful for building fish traps (to get food faster), sawmills (to get lumber faster) and necessary to start a mine. You can buy plenty of great things in the trading post, which makes nice chrome. Since you basically get a single move and action, turns can fly by (once the world is explored a bit). In fact, I don’t think our game lasted 70 minutes, like the geek claimed.

The fact that you don’t own mines (etc) is interesting, in that it makes all the players reclusive and paranoid. The game ends when someone gets enough gold chits (each chit worth 1-2 from a river, or 3-4 from a mountain) or when you’ve explored enough of the world then via a timer. (Each turn having 1/3rd of a chance to advance the timer, which takes roughly a dozen advances to end).

We ended via the timer, and this felt unsatisfying. As the timer ticked down, the game dynamics shift. The earlier game dealt with jumping claims and running away from others. Later on the pressure means you don’t have time to isolate yourself. This creates tension (get too far away from anyone, and you can’t collude in the end game, get too close and you’ll wind up losing some of the gold you worked for). I was glad to see the game end promptly, but it felt contrary to the earlier spirit.

I’d certainly try it again, though, but I’m not desperate.


Written by taogaming

March 18, 2008 at 8:52 pm

Posted in Reviews

Tagged with

2 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. “Not desperate” to play this is how I feel, too. I’ve pretty much decided exploration games don’t work for me, but having tried enough of them, I’d say this is one of the better ones. It didn’t take long before I traded it away, though.


    March 19, 2008 at 11:28 pm

  2. There are two things that annoy me in this game.

    1) You need to get some money to get started buying tools from the shop, even just a gold or two. But to get that gold you need to get a lucky river draw, or be just after someone who gets a river gold draw and cant get it. Usually a couple people easily get early gold and are off to the races ,while the other players spend several more turn going farther and farther down the river before they manage to get their first gold, and then face a longer trek back to the shop to buy tools.

    2) The claim jumping aspect is very severe. Its very resource intensive to build a mine, AND you just spent an action doing so, and some resources doing so that you will need to extract the gold form the mine. The winning strategy is to stay near to people, with the resources needed to extract gold, and then to go use up their mine when they build it. If the other player is frustrated by your closeness and doesnt build it then you both waste your time and lose, if he builds it then you gain at least as much as him for less work.

    This makes me think the game doesnt work very well for 3 or 4 players, but could work well for two teams of 2 players each, who add together their scores at the end.


    March 20, 2008 at 2:58 pm

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: